The Best Hot Dogs in NYC – A Borough-by-Borough Guide
Savour the best hot dogs in NYC with our borough-specific guide. From Nathan’s in Coney Island to Crif Dogs in Manhattan, discover the top dogs to try!
Whether you’re a local New Yorker hunting for the best street eats, a foodie on a mission to taste iconic dishes, or a tourist looking to experience the true flavour of NYC, this guide is for you. The Big Apple is known for many things, and hot dogs are undoubtedly one of its quintessential street foods. But with countless stands, carts, and eateries vying for your attention, where exactly can you find the best hot dog in New York?
We’ve done the research, savoured the flavours, and travelled borough by borough to uncover the top spots to enjoy this beloved New York classic. From upscale toppings to no-fuss late-night staples, here’s your ultimate guide to the best hot dogs in NYC.
Manhattan’s Must-Try Hot Dogs
If you’re in Manhattan, hot dogs aren’t hard to find—but not all are created equal. Here are the standout contenders:
- Gray’s Papaya (Upper West Side)
A New York institution, Gray’s Papaya is loved for its cheap yet delicious hot dogs. Their “Recession Special” (two hot dogs and a drink) is as iconic as the hustle and bustle of NYC itself. The snappy all-beef frankfurters, slightly toasted bun, and tangy toppings deliver a perfect bite every time.
Don’t miss: Their signature papaya juice is the perfect accompaniment to combat the savouriness of the hot dog. - Crif Dogs (East Village)
If you’re looking for creativity, this underground hot dog haven is for you. Crif Dogs plays on the classic hot dog with inventive toppings, such as cream cheese, avocado, or even bacon-wrapped variations. Plus, there’s a speakeasy bar behind the restaurant—so why not make a night of it?
Top pick: The “Spicy Redneck” is not to be missed, with hot jalapeños, coleslaw, and chilli-covered goodness.
Brooklyn’s Best Bites
Brooklyn often leads the way with its artisanal and hip culinary scene, but when it comes to hot dogs, it doesn’t skip a beat either.
- Nathan’s Famous (Coney Island)
Few hot dogs in NYC are as legendary as Nathan’s Famous. Established in 1916, this institution is a bucket-list destination for food lovers, particularly if you’re in the mood for a classic dog. A trip to Nathan’s is more than just a meal—it’s an experience, right in the heart of historic Coney Island.
Pro Tip: Visit during the annual Fourth of July Hot Dog Eating Contest for prime entertainment and an unbeatable atmosphere. - Screamer’s Pizzeria (Greenpoint)
Looking for a hot dog with a twist? Try Screamer’s vegan take on this timeless snack. Their plant-based hot dogs are paired with bold, delicious toppings that make even the most devoted meat-lovers pause for a bite.
Fan favourite: The “Classic Vegan Dog” loaded with mustard, relish, and onions.
Queens’ Hidden Hot Dog Gems
Queens is NYC’s most diverse borough, so it’s no surprise that its hot dog scene offers flavours from around the world.
- The Dog House NYC (Astoria)
The Dog House NYC is a hotspot for gourmet hot dogs that break the mould. Choose from Korean-inspired options with kimchi and sesame seeds or traditional favourites topped with house-made chilli. It’s a hidden treasure for flavour enthusiasts.
Must try: The “K-Town Dog,” with spicy mayo and pickled vegetables, offers a burst of umami. - Butcher Bar (Astoria)
Known for its premium meats, Butcher Bar serves hearty, no-frills hot dogs that remind you why simple classics can be so satisfying. Each dog is grilled to perfection and served with care.
Why it’s loved: The smoky char of the beef frank beautifully enhances every bite.
Bronx Classics That Deliver
The Bronx might be best known for baseball and the Yankees, but their hot dogs hold their own.
- Frankie’s Dogs on the Go (The Bronx Terminal Market)
Frankie’s Dogs on the Go has been serving up Bronx-styled hot dogs for years, and it’s a favourite among locals for its perfectly seasoned toppings and soft, pillowy buns. Add the lively energy of the Bronx, and you’ve got yourself a winning combo.
Highlight: The “Bronx Bomber” dog, with onions, jalapeños, and melted cheese, brings the heat. - Morrone Pastry Shop and Cafe (Arthur Avenue)
Known as the Bronx’s Little Italy, Arthur Avenue combines family tradition with delicious flair. While mainly recognised for pastries, Morrone’s often surprises with unique Italian-inspired hot dogs that hit the spot.
Insider tip: Grab a hot dog to-go with a classic cannoli for dessert!
Staten Island’s Underrated Dogs
Staten Island might not always top the food list for NYC explorers, but when it comes to hot dogs, there are a few surprising gems to check out.
- DaddyO’s BBQ and Sports Bar
Known for its hearty bar menu, DaddyO’s serves hot dogs with a southern twist, featuring barbecue-inspired toppings like pulled pork and coleslaw. A true comfort food destination.
Recommendation: Their “BBQ Loaded Dog” is a burst of smoky, tangy Southern flavours. - Mike’s Unicorn Diner
For a classic American diner experience, Mike’s Unicorn Diner is an excellent option. Their old-school dogs come with the works—perfect for a nostalgic bite.
Perfect pairing: Grab a milkshake alongside your hot dog for a full throwback vibe.
What Makes NYC Hot Dogs Iconic?
New York’s hot dogs hold a special place in the hearts (and stomachs) of locals and tourists alike. Their simplicity, affordability, and accessibility make them the ultimate quick-and-tasty snack. Vendors across the city have elevated this humble dish into an art form, whether through inventive toppings, gourmet meats, or a sense of tradition passed down through generations.
Hungry Yet? Follow Your Appetite!
New York City’s hot dog scene is as diverse as its boroughs. From tried-and-true favourites to bold creations, there’s something to tantalise every tastebud—and with this guide, you’re ready to seek out the best hot dogs NYC has to offer.
Next time you’re on the hunt, remember that hot dogs in New York are a lot like the city itself—dynamic, full of character, and absolutely unforgettable. Got a favourite spot we’ve missed? Share it in the comments below or reach out to us on social media!